Wednesday, July 31, 2013

Unamuno


Unamuno has probably got the coolest sounding last name of any philosopher we have discussed thus far. But that is irrelevant.

Unamuno's philosophy basically states that doctrine doesn't determine ethics, and that we should follow our hearts. I can agree and disagree with his argument, but in all honestly I wont. Why you may ask? Because I feel like he has the same message as every other philosopher we have encountered in the course, just worded differently. “Live in the moment.” “Follow your heart.” “Reject society.” The underlying message from what I understand is to do what you want.

With Unamuno, I don't strongly oppose or strongly accept his message. I am actually more indifferent than anything. At least with Nietzsche, I could passionately voice my disdain for his message.

I guess that lately, my attention span has been getting shorter and shorter. But of course, how could it not? I have always wanted to live around the world, out of my comfort zone. I never want to settle in the same place for more time than is going to keep me satisfied. I get bored easily, and experience fuels my excitement.

Why rush into mundane responsibility? Youth is a temporary gift which gets thrown away too soon for many. The thought of getting old maddens me. I love the way I am and I wouldn't want to trade my life for anyone else's. At the same time, my ambitions taunt me every chance they get. Unlike a video game, life doesn't give instant gratification.

Something mind blowing has to happen. The universe needs to collapse an turn itself inside out. The meaning of life needs to present itself to us, just so that we can turn around and prove it wrong. Life is my drug, and I need another hit.

Tuesday, July 30, 2013

Dostoevsky


Dostoevsky is a short term visitor to our class. While not as confusing as Nietzsche, he does bring up some really stupid philosophy.

Lets say that there is a man named Bob. Bob is walking down the street and out of nowhere, a masked gunman jumps out of a nearby bush, pointing a loaded pistol at his head. While Bob stands there shaking and defecating himself, the gunman drops a pillow case filled with nothing but perfectly cut pink diamonds. Now the gunman gives Bob a choice. He has the choice whether to take the sack or to get shot in the face.

What are the stipulations?

There are none.

Is there a catch?

No.

What happens afterwards?

You get extremely rich or you die.

Let's say Bob is a reasonable gentleman. As a reasonable gentleman, Bob does what anybody would do. He takes the sack of diamonds and becomes an extremely rich man. The masked gunman is never seen again. Bob lives happily ever after. Dostoevsky categorizes the majority of people as gentlemen or gentlewomen.

Now let's say Bob is the underground man. As the underground man, he knows that there are no stipulations and he is very well aware of what will happen depending what he chooses. However, just for the hell of it, he puffs out his chest and lets out a defiant “No!” Of course, he gets shot in the head and dies with no honor and no gain of any sort. Stupid right? Well, for whatever reason, Dostoevsky admires the underground man.

The only person that I can think of as being the underground man is Peter Griffin.






Now I find Dostoevsky comical at best. His philosophy serves as a comic relief after Nietzsche and all of the nonsense that he was throwing up all over our minds. Dostoevsky is the clown that you see in the hospital after a traumatic brain injury.

Saturday, July 27, 2013

Nietzsche IV


Finally we an move away from Nietzsche. I can honestly say that there is very little Nietzsche philosophy that I can agree on. Now he is talking about our lives being infinite loops? Nay, I disagree with thee Nietzche.

This is probably the first time in class where I just couldn't take anything seriously. Maybe I'm just way too brainwashed to think on an abstract level as Nietzsche, but for the most part, his philosophy is a bunch of gibberish. It's already frustrating that he writes in a bunch of confusing metaphors, but what makes it even worse is that his message also doesn't make any sense.

Why did Nietzsche fall into a state of dementia? Was his philosophy just that mind blowing that it made him go crazy? Did he really believe what he wrote? What was really underneath the mustache? Maybe the real secret to his philosophy was under that mountain of hair under his nose.

Now I know this post is more of a rant than it is informative, but after the first three classes on Nietzsche. My mind is pretty much made up. He doesn't speak to me in a way that makes sense. What comes from Nietzsche's writings is the equivalent of what comes out of my neighbor's mouth when he forgets to take his pills. It may make sense to him, however, it is counterproductive in the real world.

The man influenced Hitler. Who wants to be like Hitler? Not I said the sheep-hawk.

Friday, July 26, 2013

Nietzsche III


Master morality versus slave morality. What is the difference? Master morality pertains to the elite aristocracy and slave mentality pertains to the lower class. The values of the master are defined as good and bad while the values of the slave are good and evil. These values conflict with one another however. Good in the master sense pertains to honor, courage and nobility while bad is basically dishonor, cowardice and overall weakness. In the slave sense, compassion and kindness are good values while impending fear beyond their control is evil.

In the example of the hawk and the lamb, the master is portrayed as the hawk while the slave is portrayed as the sheep. Naturally, their values conflict. What is lunch to a hawk is death to a lamb. Their sense of good is different from one another.

In class, we were asked whether we saw ourselves as the master or the slave. With the master being a douche-bag and the slave being such a victim, I couldn't raise my hand for any of them. I don't see my morality as being totally master or totally slave. In fact, I don't know many people who can be exclusively in one category.

What would Martin Luther King be categorized in? He is probably one of the most courageous and noble figures in the course of American history, but his work consisted of suffering and peaceful struggle. He has the courage of the master and the compassion of the slave. Surely, he can't be categorized in one group.

The balance between the two moralities is almost essential in a great leader in my opinion. Too much of master breeds Hitler and too much of slave breeds an unknown coward. I like to consider myself as a sheep-hawk with more hawk like tendencies. I would not want to be one or the other. Therefore, Nietzsche, I disagree with thee.

Thursday, July 25, 2013

Nietzsche II


All truth is subjective. At least thats what Nietzsche thinks. Nietzsche's philosophy makes as much sense as an Alice in Wonderland acid trip. The concept of what he is saying makes sense if you look at it in a certain perspective, however I completely disagree with him.

To say that truth is all subjective is to say that everything is made up by the individual. Are we really that powerful to where any truth can be altered just by believing it enough? With the subject of truth, a lot of what ifs get thrown around. What if someone is delusional? What if you are outside the realm of reason? For one thing, how would one even know if there is a realm outside of reason? Also, delusional is just that, delusion. The universe doesn't change it's laws because one person can't comprehend reality.

Math by itself can disprove Nietzsche. One plus one equals two. Now disprove that. Unless there is any way to disprove that universal statement, I will never accept that truth is all subjective. If you cut something in half, then you have two halves of that one object. The person who says otherwise is just wrong. Even when concerning tribes who don't understand the concept of numbers, the logic of math is still the same. If one gazelle runs by and then another gazelle runs behind that one, then there are two gazelles. If there is some other way to look at it, prove it to me.

The simple fact that there are things in this world that you can prove indefinitely shows me that there has to be an objective truth. Even if somebody sees themselves as a glass of orange juice tipping over during a heavy salvia trip, the world still doesn't change its laws. Nietzsche puts more power into an individual than is conceivable by human means.

Maybe I'm just crazy.

Wednesday, July 24, 2013

Nietzsche I


Yesterday we started on Friedrich Nietzsche. After reading the required text, most of the class was confused on what exactly Nietzsche was trying to convey to people. Just like every other existentialist writer, he fills his text with a ton of flowery language. The excerpt that we focused on was the madman from “The Gay Science.”

Who exactly is the madman? From what I understand, the madman is supposed to be a prophet of some sort. However, he must be one of the earlier prophets because people still look at him as crazy. The madman is one of the first humans to evolve into a higher consciousness.

God has been killed by rationality and science according to Nietzsche. Because science and rationality start to take over, Christian values are becoming more and more obsolete and Nihilism starts to set in. Therefore, Nietzsche calls for a new set of vales to compliment the coming of the new age.

The discussion in class made figuring out Nietzsche easier. Coming into class, the text was really just a bunch of nonsense. However, when we got together and prodded deeper into the reading, the material began to make sense. Unfortunately, most of it still doesn't make any sense. This leads me to believe that existentialism is the “Where's Waldo” of philosophy. There is a hidden meaning in every text. I wonder why the real meaning is buried so neatly in between the language used.

Tuesday, July 23, 2013

Kierkegaard III


Yesterday's class was pretty fun. We discussed Kierkegaard's position on the aesthetic, the ethical, and the religious. As an overview, the aesthetic is the freest of the the states, but is the emptiest as well. It is a state concerned with the self. The ethical is the state where one gives up self interest for the good of the community or family. The idea of sin starts to settle into the ethical state and as a result, one hovers toward the religious state. In the religious state, one's life is fulfilled because they become in touch with God. However, the religious state is also the most irrational. This is the state where people try to prove subjective truth with objective reasoning, which Kierkegaard states is impossible.

In our groups, we discussed what Kierkegaard would say to Clemence if they met up at the same bar in Amsterdam. We found that they would probably agree on some things and disagree on more. Our table had good points for each side, but in the end, it was like comparing apples and oranges.

The end of class was fairly entertaining as Heston and I became Clemence and Kierkegaard and reenacted what could have been a conversation of theirs. Eventually Heston got bombarded with questions and I didn't have to say much of anything until the end of class.
 
Friedrich Nietzsche is next. Enough said.

Saturday, July 20, 2013

Kierkegaard II


I have a puppy. His name is Poochie. He likes to take walks and chew on everything. He has an adorable face that you just can't say no to. However, no matter how how much I wish it, Poochie will never become a dragon. On the other hand, while I may see Poochie as a puppy, somebody may come along and consider him the second coming of Christ. While that person has no proof to support their claim, I also have no evidence to prove them wrong. That is the gist of what Kierkegaard talks about when he describes objective and subjective truths.

Objective truth can be contrasted in my first example. It can be proven that Poochie is a puppy, and to say otherwise is just plain wrong. Any claim that is unanimously considered a fact is an objective truth. But while Poochie is obviously not a dragon, it can't be proven that he is not the second coming of Christ. If someone was to worship him, while I would think that person is an idiot, I couldn't exactly say that he is wrong. It is a faith based claim which that person came up with, also known as a subjective truth.

Kierkegaard has a serious problem with people trying to turning subjective truth into objective truth. So I can only imagine that if Kierkegaard was alive today, he would have a problem with Stephen Hawking claiming that he can prove the nonexistence of God (Haley knows my position on this). He takes the position that science and belief can't be seen in the same light. Science needs to stick with science while religion needs to stick with religion.

While Kierkegaard writes in a way which is hard to understand, his philosophy makes sense to me. I didn't understand so much of the first day's discussion, but that was mainly because I had read the wrong reading. What I wrote yesterday should actually be my blog for Monday. Sorry for the confusion.

Friday, July 19, 2013

Kierkegaard I


Good bye Camus, hello Kierkegaard. Kierkegaard, unlike Camus, is a religious Existentialist. However, the Church doesn't care for him so much. Likewise, Kierkegaard is not opposed to talking smack about the Church. He views the Church in the same way that one would view a flock of sheep. They all just go with whatever doctrine the Church comes out with without question, because they fear the wrath of God. In a way, Kierkegaard brings a fresh new look to Christianity, in the form of existential philosophy.

In the reading, Kierkegaard describes three types of “spheres.” The aesthetic sphere is the one with the most freedom. However, the aesthetic is said to get stuck in the same loop continuously and their life has no true meaning. This is due to living only for one's own pleasure. The ethical sphere comes about when one lives for other people as opposed to living for oneself. Kierkegaard emphasizes that marriage is what ultimately defines the ethical sphere. The last one is the religious sphere. In this sphere, one lives in the eyes of God, and is transcended to a higher state. With this sphere comes a lack of reason or logic.

I think that Kierkegaard is easier to read than Camus. Although Kierkegaard is religious, he doesn't shove church doctrine down our throats and expect us to swallow it. Although, except for a few small excerpts, we haven't really read too much of Kierkegaard's actual writings. I am curious as to what he will enlighten us with.

Thursday, July 18, 2013

The Fall II


What gives us the right to judge others? Clamence has the notion that in order to be a judge, one must become a judge penitent. In other words, the judge must be judged before they can do any judging. Because of his extreme arrogance, he assumes that he is given the right to judge based on this notion.

 The quote that we were given in class to discuss was interpreted in several different ways. The majority of the class agreed that the stroke of genius that Clamence was referring to was that the judge penitent was to become the judge. Upon reading the quote further, I found the stroke of genius to be found in his reference to Copernicus. When he says to “reverse the reasoning to win out,” he almost implies that we should lie about our beliefs if they should bring us into any type of danger. Had Copernicus stood his ground when talking about the world revolving around the sun, he would have surely been killed. Who want's to die for an idea? That would be ultimately egotistical.

Fortunately, we are starting Kierkengaard later today. Camus wrote in a very artistic way, however, I found him to be a little too depressing for my taste. His view on life was that of futility. He makes it seem like the world is such an unfortunate place. Camus is like a raincloud that covers the sky with no end in sight. Therefore, it is harder for me to accept his views on life.

Unlike Camus, I can't accept the notion that there is no point to life. In my opinion, a life that is only lived for death defeats the whole purpose of living. However, what do I know?

Tuesday, July 16, 2013

The Fall I


“The Fall” by Albert Camus was the topic for today's class. We first got into a circle and discussed the reading. I admitted that the reading was pretty hard to understand and that there were bits and pieces of the story that I couldn't remember. I guess this was okay because some of the other class didn't understand that well either.

The story started to make more sense the more we discussed it. It is basically the story of a prestigious lawyer named Jean-Baptiste Clamence who gradually fell from his high horse in society but remained with his prideful attitude throughout the story.

After the circle discussion, we got into our small groups. First, we had to tell a story of the stupidest thing that we have ever done. In my case, I have done a multitude of stupid things in my lifetime, so picking one wasn't that difficult. I still don't understand the meaning of that exercise.

The concept of the book became easier to grasp once we had discussed more about it in our groups. We discussed the three events that lead to Clamence's fall, which were the woman's suicide, the motorcycle incident, and the laughter. All of these events led him to reevaluate his life and in turn, move to Amsterdam. More specifically, he moved into the center ring of Amsterdam, which also happens to be the red light district.

Because I had a hard time understanding the text, I don't have much of an opinion on it. I will definitely have to read it again.

Friday, July 12, 2013

Sisyphus II


What is the point? The question regarding whether life has meaning was the big topic for today's discussion. In fact, the topic turned into a big argument, which seemed to bring about the same conclusion later on. There was some frustration in the room, but the argument brought about some different perspectives.

With the type of language that Camus uses, it is difficult to come to a solid conclusion of what he is trying to say. Therefore, different sides come out. Life and meaning is an argument that will never have a conclusion. It is absurd, just as Camus likes it.

This is my fifth blog post and I don't feel any smarter than the first day I started. The discussions bring out some interesting ideas, but I don't feel like I would apply this knowledge to my life. What is living in the moment exactly? Do any of us truly live day by day? How does one live without ever planning for the future, no matter how distant? Moments come and go so fast. Aren't you bound to miss one of them? Do all of these questions put me into tier 3?

This is absurd.

Wednesday, July 10, 2013

Sisyphus I


“The Myth of Sisyphus” is the topic of discussion recently. Camus used the Greek myth in order to paint a picture of how absurd life is. He basically says that our lives are of no greater importance than Sisyphus, who spends eternity pushing a rock up a hill. Although the message of Camus is depressing, the character of Sisyphus is happy through Camus's eyes.

I agree and disagree with Camus's message in “The Myth of Sisyphus.” In a universal sense, our lives are absurd, and life doesn't carry much importance. However, I believe that it is also an arrogant statement. Life doesn't make much sense at all if you are looking at it through the eyes of a spectator. In a greater sense, we can look at our lives in the same light that we see an ant colony. Our lives are filled with patterns and routine, then we die. Like ants, some of us unfortunately die prematurely, while others continue their routines until they get too old and die. While absurd through our eyes, I'm sure the ants think they are accomplishing something of greater importance.

It is argued that our lives only hold importance to us because we give it meaning. That is true, but just because we give it importance, does that make our lives any less important? Could it be that importance is something that life came up with in the first place? If there was no such thing as life, would there be such a thing as importance?

Our brains can't fathom the vastness of the universe. Therefore, I have a hard time believing that such a simple conclusion about how important our lives are is in itself absurd. Just because it doesn't make sense in our eyes, life may have it's own agenda for us. I'm a firm believer that people aren't as smart as they think they are.

Rolling a stone up a hill for eternity may look like a pointless task when viewing from an external viewpoint. However, Camus points out that in the eyes of Sisyphus's, the importance of life comes from rolling the same rock up the hill forever. I wonder if he knows something we dont.

The Stranger II


Today's class was focused on the second act of “The Stranger” by Albert Camus. With our peer groups, we discussed a couple of themes of the story. We discussed how guilt was interpreted in the story. Personally, I thought that Meursault had no real feelings of guilt. The guilt was in the eyes of society. In the court of law, his actions considered him guilty. In the eyes of the church, he should show remorse for his actions. However, because of his view of life, Meursault felt no guilt for his actions. In fact, he was excited about the fact that he would get to start another life over.

Meursaults character can be admired as well as despised. It is admirable that even in the midst of certain death, Meursault doesn't base his life decisions on what is expected of him. While most people would bow to the comfort of being saved when facing death, Meursault accepts his life as it is and embraces the inevitable. While admirable, Meursault's view on life was what ultimately led to his life being cut short. It would have made a lot more sense not to shoot the Arab and leave the fight. The act of murder he committed was senseless.

Meursault's fascination with the sun rising was an event that occurred throughout the story. It makes me wonder whether Meursault was talking about an afterlife when he said that he was excited for the next life. Since he lived day by day, maybe his next life would start the next morning.

Monday, July 8, 2013

The Stranger I


After a long Independence Day weekend, the topic of discussion for our class has become Albert Camus's “The Stranger.” More specifically, we focused on Meursault's personality and how he is perceived in the first act, further understanding the existentialist mind set.

Meursault is a nonchalant character who lives his life without caring about the consequences of his actions. Besides a few oddities, Meursault is really just a normal guy who doesn't express much emotion if at all. This is made clear during the funeral, where his carefree attitude toward his mother's death sends an unsettling message to others around him.

Marie, who is Meursault's girlfriend, is treated well by him. However, Meursault shows about as much passion for her as he would a goldfish. For example, when the issue of marriage comes up, he simply states that he would marry her only because it would make her happy. The act of marriage, in his eyes, is meaningless.

The moment that defined Meursault during act one was when he was at the beach and the Arab pulled a knife on him. Meursault shot him once, then four more times afterwards for no good reason really. Although a lot of the blame goes to Meursault, the Arab man should have known not to bring a knife to a gun fight.

A life without having a care in the world is a seductive idea. Living in the moment all of the time would lessen the instance of worrying, however, it could get one into trouble, such as in Meursault's case. A life without any passion is meaningless. It is easy to live day by day without anything to reach for. If there is nothing to live for, then what is the point in living at all?

Thursday, July 4, 2013

Wednesday July 3


Walking into class today, I didn't know what to expect. I had read the introduction to existentialism the night before, but none of the text made any sense to me. Coming into class, I had seen a whole new set of faces, in a classroom setting that was all new to me. Sitting in a circle, we all introduced ourselves and gave a brief story about our lives. Some people, such as myself, kept the story short, while other people had stories that led to longer discussions. It was kept lighthearted with the atmosphere of the classroom being more interactive rather than dissociated.

Thought provoking discussions were brought up during the introduction. There was a multitude of personalities who all had something unique to say about themselves. Some had hobbies to share, some had life experiences, and some had arguments. Everyone had something to contribute. During the discussions, the case of “reading the introduction” came up. I was relieved to know that I wasn't the only one who didn't understand the material. In fact, I learned that the whole point of reading it was to show how much we don't understand.

Due to the amount of material I don't understand, I read the introduction over again to see if any of it made any more sense. The theme of existentialism is that of a journey to achieve personal freedom. In order for that to happen, we must sacrifice a little bit of our morality. It calls plenty of abstract thinking.
Seeing that I am just being introduced to this course, there are still many questions that I may have. I do like how the course is pushing me to expose myself. Over the course of my post military life, I have become somewhat of a hermit with little interaction with other people. The feeling of exposure this class brings is what I feel I need out of school right now. I am like a baby being thrown into a swimming pool, with my classmates being my floaties.

I have never made a blog before, so I hope that this one is clear and easy to access. This unique way of doing homework tells me that most of us have to get out of our comfort zone. The idea of self exposure is pretty radical, and I am delighted to see what concepts I can grasp from this course.