Dostoevsky is a short term visitor to our class. While not as confusing as Nietzsche, he does bring up some really stupid philosophy.
Lets say that there is a man named Bob. Bob is walking down the street and out of nowhere, a masked gunman jumps out of a nearby bush, pointing a loaded pistol at his head. While Bob stands there shaking and defecating himself, the gunman drops a pillow case filled with nothing but perfectly cut pink diamonds. Now the gunman gives Bob a choice. He has the choice whether to take the sack or to get shot in the face.
What are the stipulations?
There are none.
Is there a catch?
No.
What happens afterwards?
You get extremely rich or you die.
Let's say Bob is a reasonable gentleman. As a reasonable gentleman, Bob does what anybody would do. He takes the sack of diamonds and becomes an extremely rich man. The masked gunman is never seen again. Bob lives happily ever after. Dostoevsky categorizes the majority of people as gentlemen or gentlewomen.
Now let's say Bob is the underground man. As the underground man, he knows that there are no stipulations and he is very well aware of what will happen depending what he chooses. However, just for the hell of it, he puffs out his chest and lets out a defiant “No!” Of course, he gets shot in the head and dies with no honor and no gain of any sort. Stupid right? Well, for whatever reason, Dostoevsky admires the underground man.
The only person that I can think of as being the underground man is Peter Griffin.
Now I find Dostoevsky comical at best. His philosophy serves as a comic relief after Nietzsche and all of the nonsense that he was throwing up all over our minds. Dostoevsky is the clown that you see in the hospital after a traumatic brain injury.
No comments:
Post a Comment