Thursday, July 25, 2013

Nietzsche II


All truth is subjective. At least thats what Nietzsche thinks. Nietzsche's philosophy makes as much sense as an Alice in Wonderland acid trip. The concept of what he is saying makes sense if you look at it in a certain perspective, however I completely disagree with him.

To say that truth is all subjective is to say that everything is made up by the individual. Are we really that powerful to where any truth can be altered just by believing it enough? With the subject of truth, a lot of what ifs get thrown around. What if someone is delusional? What if you are outside the realm of reason? For one thing, how would one even know if there is a realm outside of reason? Also, delusional is just that, delusion. The universe doesn't change it's laws because one person can't comprehend reality.

Math by itself can disprove Nietzsche. One plus one equals two. Now disprove that. Unless there is any way to disprove that universal statement, I will never accept that truth is all subjective. If you cut something in half, then you have two halves of that one object. The person who says otherwise is just wrong. Even when concerning tribes who don't understand the concept of numbers, the logic of math is still the same. If one gazelle runs by and then another gazelle runs behind that one, then there are two gazelles. If there is some other way to look at it, prove it to me.

The simple fact that there are things in this world that you can prove indefinitely shows me that there has to be an objective truth. Even if somebody sees themselves as a glass of orange juice tipping over during a heavy salvia trip, the world still doesn't change its laws. Nietzsche puts more power into an individual than is conceivable by human means.

Maybe I'm just crazy.

1 comment:

  1. Excerpt from my blog-

    "Moving on to another example I made in class on the nature of truth, I was asked how to prove, given lack of objective truth, that 1 + 1 could equal something other than 2. This, I feel, I am more capable of answering.

    Take for example, the mathematical fact that the repeating decimal, .99999999999... etc is equal to 1. So, as a society, we agree on this as a mathematical fact; there seems to be a certain truth about it and to it. But let's say that "1" is a pie, and we took away .0000000000000000...1 percent of it away, the tiniest possible crumb that could still be considered part of the pie. Now, I would argue that subjectively, the pie is no longer entirely whole, as we've taken the tiniest crumb away from that pie. Follow?

    Now let's say we did that with 2 pies, two separate pies. So we've got .9999999999999 of one pie and .99999999999999 of the other pie; for all intents, when we look at them, we see two pies. But when we consider the tiniest little piece that we've taken away, is it not the case that they are in fact now incomplete, adding to 1.9999999999999..8 pies, in essence?"

    For the record, I don't believe that Nietzsche actually follows the view that all truth is subjective. I think he's offering it as a thought experiment, in order to see things through a different, unique perspective. To me, the argument is that we're all stuck in our own mind, and there's no way to prove things without a shadow of a doubt. It's not that "there is no truth", it's more that "there is a possible universe where there is no truth, and there's no possible way to prove that this is not that universe".

    I'd love to continue this, and I hope you respond, because I'm fascinated by the concept of truth and reality. Epistemology and the study of our individual perspectives is probably my favourite set of concepts, simply because it's so... subjective. There are so many different ways to see such simple concepts.

    I think another way of describing this set of phenomenon is to look at the dream state in humans- our senses are firing, we're getting input while we're in REM sleep, but as our body paralyzes our physical form, we don't move. With that in mind, how can you be positive that the dream world is, necessarily unreal while you're in it? Is that possible, while dreaming? What if you realize it's a dream, and when you try to wake up, you wake up into another dream that you DON'T recognize is a dream and then you continue your life from there? How can you be sure of an objective truth if you have no objective perspective, in these cases?

    ReplyDelete